June 9, 2025

— Joseph Welch

↓ ↓ ↓ ↓ ↓ ↓

Hey look, a chance to support the newsletter!

Sponsored by: Brain.fm​ Transform Your Focus With Brain.fm​ We know you’re always on the hunt for tools that genuinely improve your life—which is why we're excited to introduce you to Brain.fm's groundbreaking focus music. ​Brain.fm’s patented audio technology was recently validated in a top neuroscience journal, showing how it actually changes your brainwaves to enhance concentration. They even offer a specialized ADHD mode, specifically engineered for brains that process attention differently. ​Brain.fm is a powerful companion for any serious writing or deep thinking work. Here's why I recommend Brain.fm: Science-backed technology that creates measurable neural changes Specialized modes for different brain types, including ADHD Works within minutes of listening Focus modes for any task, including deep work, creativity, learning, and more Also supports Sleep, Meditation, and Relaxation For a limited time, our readers can get a full month of Brain.fm for free. Try Brain.fm Free for 30 Days →

​

Please let me know here if you can't see the ads. Thanks!

↑ ↑ ↑ ↑ ↑ ↑

'I will not discuss it further'

This is the story of two Josephs.

The first Joseph wore his plain suits kept his words precise.

He was not a man given to shouting, nor to theatrical outbursts. If he was going to hurt you, he would do it gently—with a pause, a raised eyebrow, and a sentence sharpened to a point. You might not even know you’d been cut until the silence that followed.

He was born on a cold day in Iowa, in the year 1890, seventh and youngest child of a family with no wealth, no special pull. His father ran a general store. His mother taught school. They lived modestly and expected little more than hard work and decency from their son.

His name was Joseph Welch. He gave his parents both.

He went to Grinnell College, then law school at Harvard, graduating near the top of his class. Joined the Army for World War I, but the conflict ended before he finished training. He returned in Boston, eventually becoming a partner at a white-shoe firm, where he made a reputation not as a firebrand or a courtroom showman, but as a man of steadiness and poise.

He had a gift for asking the right question and knowing when not to ask it. He did not seek the spotlight. And yet, one day, it found him.

The second Joseph

The early 1950s in America were tense years. The Cold War had begun, and with it came a fear that communists were everywhere—hiding in unions, government offices, schools, even the military. To many, the threat seemed not just external, but internal. Suspicion became a public ritual. Careers were ruined by whispers. Names were blackened in hearings that were long on accusation and short on evidence.

At the center of it all stood a junior senator from Wisconsin: the second Joseph, Senator Joe McCarthy.

Loud, forceful, untiring. He waved papers. He named names. He held press conferences and hearings and investigations. He claimed to be the lone warrior standing between the American public and communist subversion. Many feared him. Some supported him. Few stood up to him.

And then came the Army-McCarthy hearings.

They asked Welch

The senator had turned his focus toward the U.S. Army, alleging that it had harbored and protected communists in its ranks. The Army pushed back, and a public hearing was scheduled to settle the matter. Televised live, the hearings became a national spectacle—a duel between a man who saw traitors behind every door and the institutions that now found themselves forced to respond.

The Army needed counsel. A lawyer. A man who could speak plainly, calmly, but with weight. Someone who could sit before the cameras and the American people and not blink.

They asked Welch.

He was nearly 64 years old, with zero political ambitions, no wish to become a household name. But he said yes. Out of duty, out of a sense that something had gone badly wrong in American life, maybe out of a feeling that he'd missed the chance to serve when he was a young nam, and this was his opportunity.

For several weeks, Joseph Welch watched as Joseph McCarthy attacked his client, questioned witnesses, accused, insinuated -- then did it again. Welch's strategy was not to meet fire with fire, but to let the McCarthy burn himself out.

Perhaps that would’ve worked, given time. But on June 9, 1954, 71 years ago today, something changed.

That day, the senator tried a different tactic. He attacked one of Welch's young colleagues—a junior associate from his Boston law firm—accusing the young man of having communist ties from law school, years earlier. McCarthy had held the name until just the right moment, intending it as a trap, a bomb to be dropped mid-hearing.

He dropped it, and the room fell still.

'No sense of decency?'

Welch spoke quietly. But each word landed like a hammer on granite.

The senator tried to interrupt, but the lawyer waved him off: “Let us not assassinate this lad further, Senator.”

Then came the line—the one that would echo far beyond the chamber, across television screens, into editorials and history books:

There was no applause. McCarthy tried to continue, but Welch had had enough.

The hearings continued, but the momentum shifted. The public, once fearful or uncertain, saw the senator differently now. The aura of righteousness had cracked.

By year’s end, the Senate would censure him. Within a few years, his political career was over. He died young, his influence long since faded.

Standing up for principle

As for the Welch, he did not seek to capitalize on the moment -- except that he did take advantage of the opportunity to appear in a movie unrelated to the hearings: Anatomy of a Murder, in which he played a judge.

He was nominated for a Golden Globe, but he wasn’t really a performer. He was, to the end, a man of law. A man who believed that public power should be exercised with restraint, that accusations should be made with care, and that decency—though not always fashionable—was a line that must not be crossed.

He died in 1960, just six years after the hearings.

He didn’t seek glory. He never raised his voice. But in one moment, before a nation on edge, he stood up—not for politics, not for party, but for principle.

And on June 9, 1954, he reminded America what decency sounds like.

​If you aren't also subscribed to Understandably, you can follow me there!

Did you see ...

• President Trump called up 2,000 California National Guard troops over the objection of the state's governor and began deploying them in Los Angeles after unrest over federal immigration roundups in that city. Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth warned he was considering sending active duty U.S. Marines from nearby Camp Pendleton to L.A. as well. Also, Trump's "border czar," Tom Homan, warned that Newsom and Los Angeles Mayor Karen Bass, whom he accused of "creating a sanctuary for criminals," would face arrest if they impeded ICE agents in the city. (NBC News)
• Elon Musk deleted his posts on X attacking Trump after Trump warned there would be “serious consequences” if Musk, who dedicated a quarter of a billion dollars to getting Trump elected last year, were to switch sides and support Democrats. One of Musk's now-deleted posts accused Trump of featuring prominently in the Epstein files: “@realDonaldTrump is in the Epstein files. That is the real reason they have not been made public. Have a nice day, DJT!” (Mediaite)
• Ukraine’s shock drone strike on Russia’s strategic bomber fleet last week has generals and analysts taking a new look at threats to high-value United States aircraft at bases in the homeland and abroad – and the situation is worrisome. “We are pretty vulnerable,” retired US Army Gen. Stanley McChrystal told CNN. War game simulations and analyses show “the overwhelming majority of US aircraft losses would likely occur on the ground at airfields (and that the losses could be ruinous),” says one report on the idea that China would make such an attack in case of war. (CNN)
• Four leaders of the Proud Boys who were pardoned after being found guilty of trying to keep Trump in power on Jan. 6, 2021 sued the U.S. government for $100 million. (Reuters)
• Kilmar Abrego Garcia, whose mistaken deportation to El Salvador became a political flashpoint, was returned to the United States on Friday to face criminal charges of human smuggling. If convicted, he will be re-returned to El Salvador at the conclusion of the case, officials said. (AP)
• At least $1.7 trillion languishes in lost or forgotten 401(k) accounts, with an average unclaimed balance of $56,616. Those 29 million idle accounts represent one quarter of all assets held in 401(k) retirement plans: “Even 10 or 15 years ago, if you put in $5…, $6…, $7,000, that could be worth three, four, or five times as much today.” (USA Today)
• This story might be funnier if you have a military background, but maybe it translates. A Marine Corps sergeant accidentally wrote an email for her bosses asking to send a corporal to a routine military school, but accidentally sent it to a distribution list including practically the entire Marine Corps leadership. "Who the hell is Corporal Hundley?" became a Marine Corps-wide joke, and Marines started a Change.org petition to get the top 4-star USMC general to attend the corporal's graduation. They got the second-best thing when the top sergeant major showed up instead. (Task & Purpose; Instagram)