September 15, 2025“I'm going to let the public serve themselves. It's going to work because it makes sense.” — Clarence Saunders. ↓ ↓ ↓ ↓ ↓ ↓ Hey look, a chance to support the newsletter! Please let me know here if you can't see the ads. Thanks! ↑ ↑ ↑ ↑ ↑ ↑ $500 and a prayerPicture this: You're sitting at your kitchen table in Fresno, California, sipping morning coffee on a perfectly ordinary Tuesday. The mail arrives. Among the bills, you find something unexpected—a piece of plastic with your name embossed across the front, accompanied by a letter explaining that you now possess $300 in instant credit. No application. No background check. No visit to the bank. Just trust. This was September 18, 1958, and Joseph P. Williams had just unleashed the most audacious financial experiment in American history. Williams wasn't a banker—he was a former infantry officer who'd talked his way into Bank of America by driving cross-country and begging legendary founder A.P. Giannini for a job. By the mid-1950s, he was running the bank's think tank, tasked with solving an increasingly obvious problem. The Problem That Wasn't Supposed to ExistMiddle-class Americans were drowning in paperwork. They carried multiple charge accounts—Sears, Mobil, local department stores. Each came with separate bills, payment dates, and credit policies. It was financial chaos disguised as convenience. What consumers needed was obvious: one card that worked everywhere. What nobody could figure out was how to make it profitable. Diners Club and American Express existed, but they were travel cards requiring full payment each month. Small banks had tried general-purpose credit cards but lacked resources to create merchant networks. Every attempt had failed. Williams studied those failures obsessively. Then he made a crucial insight: the magic wasn't in the card itself, but in creating a three-way system where banks, merchants, and customers all benefited simultaneously. His innovation wasn't technological—it was structural. The Fresno TestWilliams chose Fresno deliberately. Population: 250,000. Big enough to matter, small enough to control. Bank of America held 45% market share there, and it was isolated—if the experiment failed, damage would be contained. On September 18, 1958, 60,000 Fresno residents opened their mail to find a BankAmericard with credit limits ranging from $300 to $500. Williams had secretly enrolled over 300 merchants beforehand. The brilliance was circular: customers received cards that immediately worked everywhere they shopped, while merchants joined a network that instantly included thousands of potential customers. It was the world's first successful "network effect" in consumer finance. Disaster and RedemptionFor three months, it looked like genius. Then reality struck. Williams had projected a 4% delinquency rate. The actual number? Twenty-two percent. Fraud exploded. Merchants complained about 6% processing fees. Police departments found themselves investigating a new category of crime. Williams resigned in December 1959. Bank of America lost over $20 million when all costs were included. Critics called it a disaster. Politicians demanded investigations. Williams was devastated—he'd gambled on human nature and lost. But Bank of America's management looked deeper. Beneath the chaos, they saw something remarkable: the concept worked. Customers loved the convenience. Merchants were making money. The infrastructure was sound—execution just needed refinement. They imposed strict controls and invested heavily in security. By May 1961, BankAmericard became profitable. The Revolution Nobody Saw ComingBank of America kept profitability secret until 1966. When truth emerged, competitors rushed in. By 1970, the program became Visa. Williams founded Uni-Serve Corporation, bought Chase's failed credit operations for $9 million, then sold to American Express three years later—proving he understood the business better than critics. Williams had created more than a payment method: a new relationship between Americans and money based on trust and instant credit. Today's Apple Pay and Venmo carry his DNA. The Fresno network effect now processes trillions annually. The transformation brought costs—consumer debt challenges and financial struggles for millions. Yet Williams solved real problems: small businesses gained customers, families managed emergencies, commerce became efficient. His insight endures: magic happens when you make it easier for everyone. Customers get convenience, merchants get sales, banks get profits. Sixty-seven years later, we're still living in the world Joseph Williams built with $20 million, 60,000 pieces of plastic, and almost naive faith in human nature. Sometimes the most revolutionary changes begin with someone willing to simply trust people with something new. If you aren't also subscribed to Understandably, you can follow me there! 7 other things to know this week ...
|
Hi. I write the Understandably daily newsletter—no algorithms, no outrage, just an essential daily newsletter trusted by 175,000+ smart people who want to understand the world, one day at a time. Plus bonus ebooks (aka 'Ubooks').
Quick note: Last week I spent a few hours with the Substack team in New York. They made a compelling pitch for me to move Big Optimism to their platform next month. I'm seriously considering it. I want to make 100% sure that no matter what happens, you keep getting this newsletter every Monday. So can I ask a favor? Sign up for the Substack version now—it takes 10 seconds and ensures you won't miss an edition if I do make the switch. Sign up here for the Substack version of Big Optimism...
October 20, 2025 "Genius is 1% inspiration and 99% perspiration." — Thomas Edison ↓ ↓ ↓ ↓ ↓ ↓ Please let me know here if you can't see the ads. You can ignore the fact that the webpage might not load — just clicking the link tells me! ↑ ↑ ↑ ↑ ↑ ↑ The Gamble By October 1879, Thomas Edison was burning through money, patience, and credibility. He'd been working on the electric light bulb for more than a year—far longer than the "three or four months" he'd confidently promised when he started....
Friends, we're a day behind due to the holiday yesterday. I hope you had a good day ("off," if you got it off), and that you enjoy today's edition. October 14, 2025 "I'm not funny. What I am is brave." — Lucille Ball ↓ ↓ ↓ ↓ ↓ ↓ Please let me know here if you can't see the ads. You can ignore the fact that the webpage might not load — just clicking the link tells me! ↑ ↑ ↑ ↑ ↑ ↑ 'You're damn right I am' In 1933, a 22-year-old struggling actress in Hollywood did what thousands of aspiring...